The Thin Red Line: Themes in Dialogue

Robert Yahnke's home page

DUALITY OF LIFE

2. Train: “Is there a war in the heart of nature? Why does nature violate itself? Is there an avenging power to nature? Not one power, but two?”

7-8. On the island. Journey to the line.

42. The mop-up battle—the Americans are victorious

57. Pvt. Witt revisits the village we saw him in at the beginning of the film.

69. On the landing craft

WITT VS. WELSH ARGUMENT:

4. Welsh: “In this world a man—by himself—is nothing. And there ain’t no world—but this one.” Witt: “I’ve seen another world.” Welsh: “Then you’ve seen things I never will.”

13. Frontal assault.

21. Col. Tall orders Capt. Staros to advance, but Staros refuses his order.

28. Welsh confronts Witt at dusk.

30. Second Night Scene

38. After the battle, Pvt. Fife and Pvt. Witt have encounters with the dead.

43-44. Pvt. Dale, the collector of teeth, confronts a dying Japanese soldier.

46. Col. Tall confronts Capt. Staros and relieves him of his command.

51. The men are given time off the line. They are all shouting and laughing and drinking.

52. Pvt. Bell’s internal flashback of his wife and his voice-over—as if reading from a letter he has written to her:

59. Mess Sgt. Storm and Sgt. Welsh talk. Wounded and dying G.I.s surround them in litters.

60. Witt and Welsh meet for a third time.

61. Third night scene

66-67. Sgt. Welsh’s transformation

 

Film resource written by Robert Yahnke
Copyright, Robert E. Yahnke, 2009
Professor, Univ. of Minnesota
Request permission from the author to reprint this resource--for educational use only

 

 

 


The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the page author.
The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by the University of Minnesota.