| |
One of the most effective ways to study ads is to have students
produce their own ads or create parodies of ads, something that
you will actually be doing at the end of this module for use in
modeling this process for your students. By having to consider techniques
and strategies for selling a product, students are having to think
about the techniques and strategies they are critiquing in ads.
Students could create a new product or consider using existing products
and then create magazine, video, or web-based ads. They could then
share their ads with peers and garner feedback as to the effectiveness
of their ads. |
Or, based on parodies/spoofs of ads in Adbusters
Magazine, students could select examples of deceptive
ads and construct their own parodies or spoofs of ads. |
False Advertising:
A Gallery of Parody
Zapavision:
Parodies of ads and movie trailers
Unofficial
Calvin Klein Ads Archive
Why
Milk—parodies of the Got Milk ads
Lampoonery:
ad parodies
Teenz247:
parodies of smoking ads
Nicknamers:
parodies of branding
Funny
Adverts: Spoof Ads
Webquest:
creating ad
Webquest:
Create an anti-pollution ad
Webquests: create anti-smoking ads
How
will you advertise your product on the WWW?
Day
One and Two: Defining the Task |
|
Teaching Activity: Parodying Ads |
Students can create their own parody of an ad for a fictitious
or actual product; you could also create a parody or spoof on an
ads such as those found in Adbusters. |
Go to the Adbusters
site on how to create your own ad:
Follow the instructions on this site that involve the following
steps:
|
- Decide on your communication
objective
- Decide on your target
audience
- Decide on your format
- Develop your concept
- The visual (you may want to select on-line
images from art-clip files or from on-line
images to insert into a Word or PowerPoint document).
- The headline
- The copy
Subheads
The signature
- Some mistakes to avoid
|
You may also want to create a parody or spoof of an ads; for examples
go to the Adbusters
site
You can also find examples
of anti-smoking ads such as the following spoof on the Malboro
ads
|
|

|
-
Write out a description of your intended message, audience,
and concept, along with a rough description of the ad itself.
-
Create the ad as a Word or PowerPoint file using clip art/Web-images.
-
Then, post your ads on the nicenet.org documents site, along
with your description of your intended message, audience, and
concept
-
Share your ad on the tappedin.org with some peers, who should
describe their perceptions of your intended message, the audience
appeals employed, and their evaluation of its overall effectiveness.
-
Compare their perceptions of the ad with your intended message,
audience, and concept, noting reasons for similarities and differences.
|
Your ad and discussion of the ad will be evaluated in terms of
your ability to:
|
-
clearly define your intended message, audience, and concept.
-
employ images, language, intertextual references, and layout
in a manner that conveys your intended message and concept,
and gain audience identification.
-
assess reasons for disparities between intended meanings and
audience responses.
|
Webquests: Advertising:
Mrs.
Horton's Advertising Webquest
Come
Swim in my River
Interpreting
advertising images
Creative
Writing Advertising Project
Media
Propoganda
AD
Dissection 101
Advertisers:
Interpreters of our dreams?
Cyberganda
Advertising
Building
an Ad Campaign
Advertising
42explore.com
|
| |
We close this module with an example of an advertising unit created
by Heather Johnson in CI5472, Spring 2002, that incorporates much
of the material covered in this module. |
AN ADVERTISING UNIT
|
I used spoof ads and regular ads from adflip.com and adbusters.com.
I transferred them onto transparencies and used them for the unit.
Go to http://www210.pair.com/udticg/lessonplans/consumerism
for worksheets that accompany this lesson. |
Teens in Culture: Do advertisements influence
or reflect teenage culture? |
INTRODUCTION: |
The objective of this unit is to make teens aware of the way
in which they are marketed by advertisers. Teens see approximately
24 hours of television a week compared to the 30 hours they are
in the classroom; discussing implications and deconstructing the
media is a key element to their processing of the ads. |
-
There are dozens of activities and ideas listed here that are
aimed at helping students focus in on the way in which the media
manipulates their attention and buying habits.
-
Accompanying the unit will be several articles from the magazine
“Adbusters” which offers students the chance to
look at ads in a different light.
-
Looking at “spoof” ads assists the students in
looking at advertising in a different light. Students will be
asked to create their own advertising pitch in the end, and
they are encouraged to use a “spoof” ad as their
marketing pitch.
-
The video “Merchants of Cool” and the “Best
Commercials of All Time” will be used in this unit to
accompany the material. |
To start off the unit, the students partake in the prompt below;
students and teacher then discuss commercials on a basic level of
entertainment. Conversation as such can easily develop, especially
when it concerns commercials, for there is a quality of the commercial
that makes it memorable and fun to discuss. (Take the hype of the
Superbowl commercials/or the Oscar commercials).
|
Ads have become a social connection among peers and coworkers,
as common phrases such as “whasssup?” enter the classroom
and other environments. Recognizing the influence of such a medium
is crucial to establish right away with students.
|
Next we delve into the ads themselves, articles about ads, spoof
ads, videos, reflection on ways in which we live in an ad-based
world, and in-class discussions. The unit and activities are enough
for at least three weeks. |
PART ONE: |
I. WHAT DO TEENAGERS WANT? Before we examine
ads, students will first reflect upon what they want, as teenagers.
By examining our desires, we may know our values. We will do some
self-reflection, gather some information and compare this data to
advertising analysis that we will do later in the unit. |
FOCUS QUESTION: What do you suppose is a utopian
solution? Think about the term and research it if you don’t
know what the word “utopian” means. |
Activity: Values Inventory
(30 minutes)
Quickwrite #1: What do you want most in life? Make a list
of things, as well as ideas and experiences. Teacher records
volunteered student answers on overhead/board. Students choose
the top 5 things on their list generated by Quickwrite #1
and record them in the first column of WORKSHEET 1 <worksheet1.htm>
Teacher discusses the second column and reviews example. Students
complete. |
|
PART TWO: |
HOMEWORK ASSIGNMENT: Ad Inventory
Using WORKSHEET 2, students will identify the ads they see from
school to home that day. They may include ads they see at school.
They will identify the place the ad is found (bus stop bench, fast
food sign, etc.) and what the ad is for WORKSHEET 2 <worksheet2.htm>. |
Activity: Assignment Review
(20 minutes)
Quickwrite #4: Reports say that teenagers see an average of
3,000 ads a day. Do you think this is true? Explain and give
evidence to support your answer. Discuss answers, which will
naturally lead to a review of last night’s assignment:
Teacher creates a composite chart of items found for last
night’s assignment and students copy. Discuss: How many
of you use or would like to use the products, services or
ideas that you saw advertised? Answers will vary. Quickwrite
#3. Discuss the last activity’s quickwrite. Answers
will vary, but urge students to consider our previous topic
of discussion (Do they use the products they saw advertised)
when answering. Some of you said that advertising does not
influence you and many of you said you are only partially
influenced by advertising. Let’s take a little quiz
to see how much you may be affected by “Branding”
add to vocabulary list <vocabulary.html> |
|
Another activity for the classroom: |
Have students pair up and chose a market they wish to explore
— teenage girls, teenage boys, young children, mothers, fathers,
grandparents, etc. Together they gather ads from this “genre”
and find patterns, flaws, deceptive things that exist within the
ads. Does it represent the audience that it is trying to sell its
product to? Or does the advertiser make it appear as if the audience
“Needs/Wants” things that are not necessary? Were there
any positive, well-represented portrayals of the audience in the
ads that you found? Project results and individual write up with
reaction to the assignment/project will be due. The students will
present their findings to the class in a two-minute presentation.
Here are some questions to be asked while analyzing a magazine:
|
-
what is the title/who does it speak to?
-
what connotations are there from such a title?
-
what audience is the magazine trying to capture?
-
what clues do you have that indicate that this is the target
market?
-
what kinds of body language is expressed in the magazine?
-
how do the different magazines of the same genre compare?
-
what products are being advertised?
-
how are men and women represented in the magazine? |
Activity: Corporate Alphabet
(15 minutes)
Teacher places Corporate Alphabet, Adbusters No. 32, Oct/Nov
2000, on overhead and asks students to silently identify the
brand names they recognize. Discuss: Brands that
appeared in the corporate alphabet. Compare: Ask students
to raise their hands if they could identify at least 10 of
these brands. Now ask them to identify something that is considered
“academically” important: i.e., Who was the fourth
president of the United States? What is the oldest and largest
species of tree? Or, ask them to identify a picture of a famous
person in history like Frederick Douglass or Sitting Bull.
They can draw their own conclusions! Discuss: Revisit Quickwrite
#3. Ask students if any of them changed their minds or want
to learn more. . . It is estimated that the average teenager
watches 24–28 hours of television a week. Compare that
to the 30 hours of classroom time. In 1996, the American Medical
Association stated, “Young people spend twice as much
time with media than they do with their parents and teachers
combined.” Add media to vocabulary list <vocabulary.html>.
As we saw in the last activity, the ads we see do affect us,
even if they are just taking up “mindspace.” In
this next activity, we will take a closer look at television
advertisements. |
|
Activity: TV Inventory
(50 minutes)
Teacher will have pre-recorded a half hour segment of prime
time TV targeted to a teen audience. Suggested programs: sit-coms,
The Simpsons, BET, MTV, etc. Student groups use WORKSHEET
3 <worksheet3.htm> to track the commercials and complete
the worksheet. Groups report findings to the class WORKSHEET
4 <worksheet4.htm> : Rate Sheet. Class examines the
rates of different TV stations As you can see, advertising
pays for the “free” programming that you watch.
These companies pay a lot of money to make sure that you get
their message. Their message is, of course, to get you to
buy a product, service or idea. They are driven to produce
an ad that effectively hooks you in the least amount of time.
So, let’s take a closer look at the ads and how they
work. |
|
PART THREE: |
ANALYZING ADVERTISING : WHAT ARE ADS REALLY SELLING? In the following
lessons, students will learn about the persuasive techniques used
by advertisements. They will identify these techniques in print
and TV ads and then analyze the messages of the ads. |
Activity: Persuasive Techniques
(50 minutes)
Quickwrite #5: Think of a time when you wanted to convince
your parent to let you do something. What did you do to persuade
him or her? Discuss answers as teacher lists the techniques
on the overhead projector. Students will generate a good list
of techniques such as logic, threats, facts, appeal to emotions:
guilt, affection, etc. Definition: persuasion, add to vocabulary
list <vocabulary.html> Distribute and review WORKSHEET
5 <Worksheet5.htm> Argumentation and Persuasion. Ask
the students to write a paragraph in which they use each of
these techniques to convince a reader that they should buy
a certain brand name product, i.e., a pair of Nike shoes or
a that they should use the Google search engine or eat at
McDonald’s, etc. (They should not identify which technique
is being used.) Students exchange paragraphs with one of their
group’s members and identify techniques generated in
the previous exercise as ethos, pathos, or logos. At the bottom
of their partner’s paper, students will write a paragraph
in which they explain which technique was most effective in
their opinion. Optional: Volunteers share paragraphs. Discuss:
How many people thought logos was the most effective? Pathos?
Ethos? Explain. |
|
Activity: TV Ad Analysis
(20 minutes)
Teacher has pre-recorded 5 primetime commercials. Student
groups use WORKSHEET 6 <worksheet6.htm> to analyze the
commercials. Discuss. |
|
HOMEWORK ASSIGNMENT:
Find two “effective” print (magazine, newspaper, internet
hard copy) ads to bring to class tomorrow. If students ask what
defines an “effective” ad, tell them that they are to
decide and we will discuss this tomorrow. |
Activity: Print Ad Analysis
(20 minutes)
Modeling: Teacher shares an ad and discusses what she likes
about it and what is effective for her personally, using terminology
from persuasion unit. She records this on the chart in WORKSHEET
7 <worksheet7.htm> WORKSHEET 8 <worksheet8.htm>:
Persuasive words used in advertising. Study this sheet and
use it to analyze their ads. Student groups share and analyze
their ads. Their task is to identify what is appealing about
the ad (colors, celebrity endorsement, humor, information,
etc.) and what persuasive techniques and words are primarily
used. Students report back to the class; depending on time,
groups may offer 2 or more things on their list. |
|
FREEWRITE ACTIVITY:
What do you think is the meaning of moral panic? |
Activity: Ads Sell Image
(50 minutes)
Quickwrite#6: Analyze this statement: Ads sell ideas, not
products. Discuss quickwrite. Examine an ad and discuss: What
do you notice first? What info is given about the product?
What is shown as important in the image? What is the lifestyle
or fantasy being promoted? What is the message of the ad?
Note: Try to get the students to notice that very little info
about the product is actually offered; instead, an image or
fantasy is created. Thus, the consumer is led to believe that
the product is the key to the lifestyle or fantasy. Examine
another ad, identifying the lifestyle being advertised. Also
ask: Who is the intended audience for this ad? Groups analyze
their ads, discussing the things or ideas that are promoted
in the ad. Groups share while teacher records the major elements
of the lifestyles that are promoted in these ads, i.e., youth,
sex, fun, money, exercise, joy, love. . . This list, made
on either butcher paper or an overhead projector transparency
sheet, will be saved to post or show later. Students revisit
WORKSHEET 1 <worksheet1.htm>. They can now complete
the third column using the ads that have already been shown
on TV or print ads brought in. If they do not find ads to
correspond to their desires, they must do so as homework. |
|
HOMEWORK ASSIGNMENT:
Find ads that correspond to your desires on your desire chart, worksheet
#1. |
Activity: Cigarette Ads
(20 minutes)
Examine a cigarette ad, identifying the fantasy that is advertised.
Examine anti-smoking ads that are “adbusters.” |
|
Activity: Adbusting
(50 minutes)
Add parody to vocab list WORKSHEET 9 <worksheet9.htm>
: Follow directions and have fun! Share and display ads. |
|
PART FOUR: |
THE TEEENAGE DEMOGRAPHIC: COOL HUNTING: Teens as Targets. In
this section, students will explore the ways in which companies
directly target them. It will be the final piece in answering the
question: Does advertising influence or reflect teen culture? Quickwrite:
Were you able to find ads that correspond to your desires? Discuss.
Advertisers hope they can appeal to your desires because they are
spending great amounts of resources to reach you, the teenage demographic.
Add demographic to vocabulary list <vocabulary.html>. |
Activity: What do Teens Value?
“Focus Groups” (40 minutes)
Discuss: Do you think many of your peers will share your desires?
How about your values? Why? In their groups, students compare
their lists in columns one and two. In their groups, students
develop a thesis statement based on this question: What do
teenagers value most? Groups share thesis statements they
may write them on tag board and post them around the room.
If I were interested in designing an ad targeting for your
demographic, I would have paid a lot of money to have listened
in on your previous discussion. I may have even paid you to
meet with me in a “focus group.” Has anyone ever
participated in a focus group? These are groups of everyday
teens like yourself who give information about your likes
and dislikes so that I may design ads that best appeal to
your sensibilities. Read: “Sweet 16,” Adbusters,
June/July 2000. Discuss: Is anyone in this room not wearing
a visible brand? Why is it important to us to identify ourselves
with brand names? Inevitably, the students will say that these
companies or products are “cool.” This will segue
into a discussion of “cool.” Optional: Why did
your group name itself after the brand name you choose? What
makes it cool? |
|
Activity: Cool Is. . .
(30 minutes)
Quickwrite #8: What is cool? List things and ideas that are
cool. Groups discuss answers and make a list of their top
coolest things. These will be posted and all students will
circulate the room, viewing the lists and trying to develop
a thesis statement. Thesis Statement: Cool, as defined by
a St. Paul teenager is __________. Cool is a value, one that
is extremely hard to even identify, let alone define. Still,
companies realize that they must be cool to be consumed by
teenagers. Here are some of the ways in which companies have
become successful by becoming cool. Read: Article 11. Quickwrite
#9: Given your understanding of these articles we just read,
do you think these companies are reflecting or influencing
teenagers? Discuss. |
|
Activity: Video Viewing: Merchants
of Cool (50 minutes)
View video (and discuss key points as you go). Freewrite brainstorm
for final essay: Does advertising influence or reflect teen
culture? |
|
Article 11 |
Slice of ’za proves brand loyalty is totally stupid! |
 |
Is the slavish brand loyalty of your peers getting you down?
Are your high school’s corridors awash in swooshes and Tommy
colors? Is every lunch hour a pilgrimage to Taco Bell or Pizza Hut?
It’s the same old story — in the struggle for personal
identity, it’s easier to buy a pre-packaged model than to
create your own. |
But it’s also easy to expose brand-name conformity with
a simple experiment. 1. Pick a brand that your peers pledge allegiance
to. For example, Pizza Hut. Corral some students in a room and order
in a pizza. 2. Blindfold your test subjects. Feed each blindfolded
person one slice of pizza, telling them it’s fresh from the
Hut. Next, feed them a second, identical slice, and tell them it’s
anything else — Uncle Albert’s Down Home Pizza, for
example. 3. Ask them which slice tasted better.
|
Ninth graders Marcelo Choi and Sean Merat tried this procedure
in their science project, “Do Commercials Work?” at
Burnaby South Secondary School in Vancouver. In their experiment,
all 16 test subjects said the Pizza Hut slice tasted better than
the other slice. |
“How can this be?” asks Merat, indignantly. “It’s
the same pizza, from the same box.”
|
Variations on the test are endless. Choi and Merat also buttonholed
loyal Nike-wearing students. While they tried on both Reebok and
Nike shoes, the blindfolded students were told they were trying
on the opposite brand. All eight test subjects said the Nike shoes
were more comfortable — then had their blindfolds removed
to discover they were wearing Reeboks.
|
That’s the moment of truth jammers live for. “Some
said Nike was still cooler,” Merat says. But a few admitted
it was time to start looking beyond the brand.
— Eliza Strickland |
CRITICAL CONSUMERISM VOCABULARY |
-
Advertisement: something that is trying to influence a person
to “buy” (or adopt) a product, service, or idea.
-
Branding: The advertising of products in such a way that consumers
have instant, positive, brand-name recognition and association
with a particular company.
-
Media: a material or technical means of expression.
-
Persuasion: the act of moving by argument to a belief, opinion,
or course of action.
-
Parody: a literary or musical work in which the style of an
author or work is closely imitated for the purpose of comedy
or ridicule.
-
Demographic: relating to the statistical study of human populations,
especially with reference to size, age, race, religion, social
class and geographic locale.
|
REFLECTION ACTIVITY: |
It seems that we have hit the ceiling cap in this digital age:
what do you think is left to invent? Where do we go from here? Do
we recycle old ideas and make them modern? |
DEFINITIONS OF PROPAGANDA TECHNIQUES |
-
Bandwagon: This technique tries to persuade everyone to join
in and do the same thing.
-
Testimonial: An important person or famous figure endorses
a product.
-
Transfer: Good feelings, looks, or ideas transferred to the
person for whom the product is intended.
-
Repetition: The product name or keyword or phrase is repeated
several times.
-
Emotional Words: Words such as luxury, beautiful, paradise,
and economical are used to evoke positive feelings in the viewer.
-
Name-calling: Negative words are used to create an unfavorable
opinion of the competition in the viewer's mind.
-
Faulty Cause and Effect: Use of a product is credited for creating
a positive result.
-
Compare and Contrast: The viewer is led to believe one product
is better than another, although no real proof is offered.
-
Ethos: The character, sentiment, or disposition of a community
or people, considered as a natural contribution; the spirit
which motivates manners and customs. Opposite of pathos.
-
Pathos: Emotions: That quality or property of anything which
touches the feelings or excites emotions and passions, especially
that which awakens tender emotions. Opposite of ethos.
-
Logos: The quality of anything that involves the use of logic
and reason.
|
Propaganda |
Many of the characteristic features of advertising and propaganda
are similar. As consumers we are both cynical and paranoid when
it comes to advertising. Although the average American is most likely
not making comparisons between advertising and propaganda, everyone
knows advertising is designed to sell more product. Advertising
is propaganda whose purpose is to develop allegiance to a product
or corporation instead of a government. |
As Professor
Widdig notes, propaganda is content-independent. He
made a short list of defining characteristics of propaganda. It
is systematic manipulation. It is geared to a mass audience. It
has high emotional density. It uses ideas that are already present,
and themes that are common to a community. It creates an "us
vs. them" mentality. It never refers to unresolved issues and
is not humorous. It uses history as raw material which it reshapes
to present its ideology as the logical outcome of history. |
All advertising is propaganda in the broadest sense of the word,
but in its own subclass we tend to distinguish it from other propaganda.
This is merely semantics, as the major impact of the word propaganda
is not its literal meaning but its rhetorical power and connotations.
Manipulation to buy a product or manipulation by a government to
support it tend to use the same methods. |
Advertising is definitely designed for a mass audience such as
television viewers or magazine readers. Content with high emotional
density is only one method advertising uses. In some ways, advertising
is more sophisticated than what we think of as traditional examples
of propaganda. It appeals to preexisting ideas in consumer culture.
We already buy lots of products. We like being competed for by companies
and products. In theory, this competition results in better products.
In practice it makes us feel valuable. The creation of an "us
vs. them" mentality is again only one of the methods advertising
uses. Other approaches emphasize the political values of a company,
use celebrity figures, or use sex appeal. |
Advertising differs, however, from propaganda in its use of humor.
Many advertisements incorporate an element of humor. In this sense,
perhaps advertising is the most advanced form of propaganda. It
is certainly the most practiced. It makes sense that it should be
the best evolved and adapted. There are also certain ethical differences
between advertising a product and convincing a nation that your
dictatorship is what they truly desire, although they are subtle. |
The web has added a new aspect to manipulation and propaganda.
Because of the nature of the web, users expect to access information
that they are choosing to access. Search engines make this possible
to a large extent. But when a search engine begins tailoring its
responses and advertising based on the subject a user is searching
on, a more subtle manipulation than ever takes place. Advertising
actually modifies itself in real time and becomes specific to each
user. |
Web sites can now give cookies, and use them to track how a user
moves through them and how often they visit and what they look for.
These sites can then present a customized form of advertising based
on this information or even send email to a user. Propaganda just
got personal. The web is just another medium and, as Widdig states,
propaganda can take place in any and all medium. Advertising is
not bad, and neither is propaganda, as long as we are aware of it
and how it attempts to manipulate us. |
Propaganda: Types of Propaganda |
BANDWAGON: The basic idea behind the bandwagon approach is just
that, "getting on the bandwagon." The propagandist puts
forth the idea that everyone is doing this, or everyone supports
this person/cause, so should you. The bandwagon approach appeals
to the conformist in all of us: No one wants to be left out of what
is perceived to be a popular trend. |
EXAMPLE: Everyone in Lemmingtown is behind Jim Duffie for Mayor.
Shouldn't you be part of this winning team? |
TESTIMONIAL: This is the celebrity endorsement of a philosophy,
movement or candidate. In advertising, for example, athletes are
often paid millions of dollars to promote sports shoes, equipment
and fast food. In political circles, movie stars, television stars,
rock stars and athletes lend a great deal of credibility and power
to a political cause or candidate. Just a photograph of a movie
star at political rally can generate more interest in that issue/candidate
or cause thousands, sometimes millions, of people to become supporters. |
EXAMPLE: "Sam Slugger", a baseball Hall of Famer who
led the pros in hitting for years, appears in a television ad supporting
Mike Politico for U.S. Senate. Since Sam is well known and respected
in his home state and nationally, he will likely gain Mr. Politico
many votes just by his appearance with the candidate. |
PLAIN FOLKS: Here the candidate or cause is identified with common
people from everyday walks of life. The idea is to make the candidate/cause
come off as grassroots and all-American. |
EXAMPLE: After a morning speech to wealthy Democratic donors,
Bill Clinton stops by McDonald's for a burger, fries, and photo-op. |
TRANSFER: Transfer employs the use of symbols, quotes or the
images of famous people to convey a message not necessarily associated
with them. In the use of transfer, the candidate/speaker attempts
to persuade us through the indirect use of something we respect,
such as a patriotic or religious image, to promote his/her ideas.
Religious and patriotic images may be the most commonly used in
this propaganda technique but they are not alone. Sometimes even
science becomes the means to transfer the message. |
EXAMPLE: The environmentalist group PEOPLE PROMOTING PLANTS,
in its attempt to prevent a highway from destroying the natural
habitat of thousands of plant species, produces a television ad
with a "scientist" in a white lab coat explaining the
dramatic consequences of altering the food chain by destroying this
habitat. |
FEAR: This technique is very popular among political parties
and PACs (Political Action Committees) in the U.S. The idea is to
present a dreaded circumstance and usually follow it up with the
kind of behavior needed to avoid that horrible event. |
EXAMPLE: The Citizens for Retired Rights present a magazine ad
showing an elderly couple living in poverty because their social
security benefits have been drastically cut by the Republicans in
Congress. The solution? The CRR urges you to vote for Democrats. |
OGICAL FALLACIES: Applying logic, one can usually draw a conclusion
from one or more established premises. In the type of propaganda
known as the logical fallacy, however, the premises may be accurate
but the conclusion is not. |
EXAMPLE:
• Premise 1: Bill Clinton supports gun control.
• Premise 2: Communist regimes have always supported gun control.
• Conclusion: Bill Clinton is a communist.
We can see in this example that the Conclusion is created by a twisting
of logic, and is therefore a fallacy. |
GLITTERING GENERALITIES: This approach is closely related to
what is happening in TRANSFER (see above). Here, a generally accepted
virtue is usually employed to stir up favorable emotions. The problem
is that these words mean different things to different people and
are often manipulated for the propagandists' use. The important
thing to remember is that in this technique the propagandist uses
these words in a positive sense. They often include words like:
democracy, family values (when used positively), rights, civilization,
even the word "American." |
EXAMPLE: An ad by a cigarette manufacturer proclaims to smokers:
Don't let them take your rights away! ("Rights" is a powerful
word, something that stirs the emotions of many, but few on either
side would agree on exactly what the 'rights' of smokers are.) |
NAME-CALLING: This is the opposite of the GLITTERING GENERALITIES
approach. Name-calling ties a person or cause to a largely perceived
negative image. |
EXAMPLE: In a campaign speech to a logging company, the Congressman
referred to his environmentally conscious opponent as a "tree
hugger." |
Ad Attack! Analysis Chart |
-
Describe the product or service presented in this ad.
-
Describe the young people portrayed in the ad: What are they
doing? What are they wearing? Where do they live? What seems
to be important to them?
-
Compare your life to theirs? How does this comparison make
you feel?
-
Would you like to be like these young people? Why or why not?
-
Circle a phrase below to rate this ad on how accurately it
portrays teens.
-
Got it right!
-
Pretty good
-
Needs a rewrite
-
Who ARE those kids?!
|
Media Awareness Test (slogan game) |
The breakfast of champions ___________________
The copper-topped battery ___________________
The nighttime, sniffing, sneezing, coughing, aching, stuffy head,
fever, so you can rest medicine ___________________
It just keeps going, and going, and going ___________________
The softer side of ___________________
The best part of waking up is ___________________ in your cup.
Good to the last drop ___________________
In the valley of the jolly (ho-ho-ho-) ___________________
Melts in your mouth, not in your hands ___________________
Best for you and all your 2000 parts ___________________
Just Do It ___________________
Kid tested, Mother approved ___________________
Must see TV ___________________
Always low prices, always ___________________
Nothing runs like a ___________________, John ___________________
Be all that you can be, in the ___________________
Yo Quiero? ___________________
Did somebody say? ___________________
It’s got to be the ___________________
It’s the cheesiest ___________________
You look so natural, no one can tell ___________________
The fastest way to send money ___________________
They care enough to send the very best ___________________
5 cents a day, every day ___________________
mmm mmm good ___________________
bargains by the bagful ___________________
|
Answer Key to media awareness test (slogan game)
Wheaties
Duracell
Nyquil
Energizer
Sears
Folgers
Maxwell House Coffee
Green Giant
M & M’s
Lever 2000
Nike
Kix
NBC
Walmart
Deere, John Deere |
Week One: Advertising Unit |
DAY ONE: (50 minutes) |
Statistic on overhead: Teens see approximately 3,000 of these
a day. -
Have students guess what this statistic could be referencing
-
After guessing, and coming up with the answer, ask students if
they think this is possible.
-
Where could 3000 ads be seen per day?
-
Have students look around the room and count the amount of ads
they see; highest count gets prize. |
Coke vs. Pepsi -
Familiar topic to all; when you think of Coke, what do you think?
-
When you think of Pepsi, what do you think?
-
What is your preference of drink? / Why?
-
Do you think that the advertisements have an effect on you?
-
If they don’t have an effect on the population, then why
are they spending millions of dollars on these advertisements?
-
Look at comparison of bottles. What are the differences? Why?
-
Look at comparison of images being sold by each product. What
audience is each targeting? Website transparency used and commercial
transparency. |
DAY TWO: (30 minutes) |
Start with slogan guessing game. Have students guess the slogan.
The preface: students stated yesterday that advertising does not
effect them, yet they are able to identify over 20 slogans in less
than a second. (10 minutes) |
Discuss different types of propaganda techniques. (10 minutes) |
Show short video that uses persuasive technique and have students
identify several techniques used in video (pitch for stadium in
St. Paul). (10 minutes) |
DAY THREE: (50 minutes) |
Students read the first two viewpoints of article and discuss
as a group what was covered in the article. (not extremely successful.
Need shorter article). (10 minutes) |
Summarize what was covered yesterday; propaganda techniques in
video, etc. Place propaganda techniques back on board and look at
specific ads, discussing different types of techniques used. (20
minutes) |
Have students look through magazines in search of ads that sell
an image more than the product. Share with class as they go. (20
minutes) |
DAY FOUR: |
Show the “Best Commercials of All Time” to students
and have them identify at least three propaganda techniques used
in the commercials. Short response paragraph also to follow the
identified propaganda techniques. (50 minutes) |
Week Two: Advertising Unit |
DAY ONE: (50 minutes) ADS SELL IMAGE |
-
Place Corporate Alphabet on the overhead. How many do you recognize?
-
How many of you still think that we are not affected by advertising?
-
Discuss this statement: Ads sell ideas, not products.
-
We look at more ads on the overhead, and students study/respond
to what the ad is saying. What techniques are being used?
-
Questions to be answered when examining an ad:
~ What do you notice first?
~ What information is given about the product?
~ What is shown as important to the image?
~ What is the lifestyle or fantasy being promoted?
~ What is the message of the ad?
-
Hand out worksheet one and have students fill in the first two
rows.
-
Do you think that many of your peers share the same desires?
-
Students get in groups of four and create a thesis statement
for their group: What, as a group do you value most? Find ads
that correspond with such desires. Volunteers share with the group
what ads they found that correspond with their desires.
-
Hand out worksheet two for the homework of the evening, due tomorrow.
|
DAY TWO: (50 minutes) PERSUASION
-
Pose this question to students at the beginning of class and
write down responses on an overhead/or chalkboard:
-
Think of a time when you wanted to convince your parent to let
you do something. What did you do to persuade him or her?
-
Discuss how propaganda surrounds our life in many ways, from
the advertising pitches that we are bombarded by, to the way in
which we try to pitch our own beliefs and expressions.
-
Hand out Worksheet Five and read through with the students. Ask
if they have questions about the handout. Give an example of the
three types of persuasion/argumentation on the overhead. Discuss.
-
Have students provide a short pitch for different products using
the three basic concepts. Partners share with the other the three
pitches and the other partner has to guess which technique was
used. Both partners share “pitches.”
-
Volunteers for the class share their pitches with the class.
-
Hand out persuasive word sheet used for ads. |
DAY THREE: (50 minutes) AD BUSTING: |
QUOTATION: Thaw with his gentle persuasion is more powerful than
Thor with his hammer. The one melts, the other but breaks in pieces.
ATTRIBUTION: Henry David Thoreau (1817–1862), U.S. philosopher,
author, naturalist |
QUOTATION: The object of oratory (speaking) alone is not truth,
but persuasion. ATTRIBUTION: Thomas Babington Macaulay (1800–1859) |
Cialdini found that successful counter ads involve the use of
effective counter-arguments that call into question the opponent's
facts and trustworthiness. Memory links to the opponent's ads, a
sponging device which essentially infects the opponent's message
by linking its memory and impact to the counter ad. Ridicule is
used to satirize the opponent's ads. |
An example of a successful ad campaign that involved all of these
elements was the anti-smoking campaign some years ago that featured
mock "Marlboro Man" commercials. Those commercials initially
looked like tobacco ads, with the same rugged outdoor settings and
same macho cowboy characters. But the counter ads then transformed
into attacks on tobacco, depicting the cowboys coughing and displaying
other health symptoms that result from smoking. This undermined
the original ads, as Cialdini said, the satirical ads made laughable
the notion that smoking was linked to images of male strength and
potency. |
What is the meaning of the word satire? One way to combat persuasion
is through the use of satire. |
SATIRE: A satire, either in speaking or in writing, holds prevailing
vices or foolishness up to ridicule: it employs humor and wit to
criticize human institutions or humanity itself, in order that they
may be remodeled or removed. |
Here is one example of satire . . . there are thousands of examples
online. (Check out The Onion, or even the Minnesota Daily archives
on-line)... |
|
Show spoof ads; begin discussing with students the ads they will
be pitching after spring break. What is the purpose of a spoof ad? |
We read the article “Sweet 16” from the AdBusters
magazine. |
What do you think of this article? |
***To illustrate other “persuasion” examples, and
just for fun (the kids really enjoy these!!): |
(With hands on shoulders) Oh, those are shoulder blades, I thought
they were wings.
If I could be anything I'd be a tear: Born in your eye, live on
your cheek, and die at your lips.
"Would you happen to have a band-aid, because I skinned my
knee when I fell for you." |
DAY FOUR: Present the assignment for spring break: The CONTEST!!!
We look at more bad ads. Show the Chevy ad again. |
There is a distinction between commercials, which are broadcast
on television, radio, and other electronic media, and advertisements,
which are found in various print media, such as magazines, newspapers,
billboards and posters. (On the Internet, the many static advertisements
are, I would suggest, best seen as electronically disseminated print
advertisements.) The following checklist focuses on print advertisements;
Chapter 6 provides a checklist for analyzing television commercials. |
The Mood |
What is the general audience of the advertisement — the
mood that is created, the feelings it stimulates? |
The Design |
What is the basic design of the advertisement? Does it use axial
balance, or are the fundamental units arranged in an asymmetrical
manner? |
What relationship exists between the pictorial aspects of the
advertisement and the copy, or written material? |
How is spatiality used in the advertisement? Is there lots of
white (blank) space, or is the advertisement crowded — full
of written and graphic material? |
Is there a photograph used in the advertisement? If so, what
kind of shot is it? What angle is it taken from? What is the lighting
like? How is color used? |
The Context and Content |
If there are figures in the advertisement (people, animals),
what are they like? Consider factors (to the extent that you can)
such as facial expressions, hairstyles and hair color, body shape
and body language, clothes, age, sex, race, ethnicity, education,
occupation, relationships, and so on. |
What does the background of the figures suggest? Where is the
action taking place, and how does the background relate to this
action? |
What is going on in the advertisement, and what significance
does this action have? Assuming that the advertisement represents
part of a narrative, what can we conclude about what has led to
this particular moment in time? That is, what is the plot? |
Signs and Symbols |
What symbols and signs appear in the advertisement? What role
do they play in stimulating positive feelings about or desire for
the product or service being advertised? |
Language and Typefaces |
How is language used in the advertisement? What linguistic devices
provide information or generate some hoped-for emotional response?
Does the advertisement used metaphor? Metonomy? Repetition? Alliteration?
Comparison and contrast? Sexual innuendo? Definitions? |
What typefaces are used, and what messages do these typefaces
convey? |
Themes |
What are the basic themes in the advertisement? What is the advertisement
about (for example, the plot may involve a man and a woman drinking,
and the theme may be jealousy)? What product or service is being
advertised? What role does it play in American society and culture? |
What political, economic, social, and cultural attitudes are
reflected in the advertisement-such as alienation, sexism, conformity,
anxiety, stereotyped thinking, generational conflict, obsession,
elitism, loneliness, and so on? |
What information do you need to make sense of the advertisement?
Does it allude to certain beliefs? Is it a reflection of a certain
lifestyle? Does it assume information and knowledge on the part
of a person looking at the advertisement? |
Hand out worksheet 7 and worksheet 8 to help them recognize “techniques.”
More examples of persuasion that gets the kids to think outside
of the advertising “box” — and they really get
a kick out of them! |
-
Hey baby, are you a parking ticket? 'Cause you got "fine"
written all over you!
-
Can I borrow your library card? I wanna check you out!
-
Are you from Tennessee? 'Cause Ten is all I See!
-
Are your feet tired? 'Cause you've been running through my mind
all day.
-
Are you Jamaican? 'Cause you're Jamaican me crazy!
-
Do you have a map? Because I'm totally lost in your eyes.
-
Well, here I am. What were your other two wishes?
-
I bet you 20 bucks you're gonna turn me down. |
What is the point of persuasion? What makes someone a good persuader?
A poor persuader? What types of persuasion work best on you? Examples:
humor, honesty, argument, etc. Why might it be difficult to turn
down someone who's trying to persuade you to do something? |