Introduction
5
A. THE PURPOSE OF
AN ADVANCE DIRECTIVE FOR MEDICAL
CARE 5
1.
Not Everyone Needs a 'Living Will'.
6
2. But if You Might Disagree with Standard Medical
Care,
You Do Need a 'Living
Will'. 7
3. Going Beyond Generic Medical
Ethics. 10
4. Your 'Living
Will' Should Not Apply in
Emergencies. 12
5. A Clear Advance Directive
Will Keep Your Death Simple and
Private.
13
B. PROBLEMS OF GENERIC 'LIVING WILLS' 15
C. THOUGHTLESS, IRRATIONAL, & MISINFORMED 'LIVING WILLS' 17
D. YOUR MEDICAL ETHICS 21
E. GETTING DOCTORS TO COMPLY WITH YOUR ADVANCE DIRECTIVE 27
F. PUT YOURSELF INTO YOUR ADVANCE DIRECTIVE 32
G. LAWMAKERS MAKE RIGHT-TO-DIE LEGISLATION 36
H. ADVANCE DIRECTIVE WORKSHOPS & OTHER DISCUSSIONS 37
I.
FOLLOW THE FORMS PROVIDED BY YOUR
STATE
38
PART I.
Scope of Your Declaration
& Appointing Proxy Decision-Makers
39
Question 1:
Should Your Advance Directive
for Medical Care apply
only when you are terminally ill or permanently
unconscious
or should it apply to all situations in which you
are not capable
of making medical decisions or are unable to express
your wishes? 39
Question 2:
What person or persons should
make medical decisions
for you if you become incapable of making your own
decisions
or unable to express your wishes?
44
A. Family Members as
Proxies. 44
B. Some Family Members Might Be
Too
Close Emotionally. 47
C. Two Kinds of Proxies:
For Routine
Decisions
and Life-Ending Decisions. 49
D. Medical Care
Decisions
Committees (MCDCs). 51
E. Proxies for Gays and Lesbians
and other
Unconventional
'Families'. 56
F. Avoid Selecting Professionals
as
Proxies. 58
G. What Will Happen If I Have No
Proxy?
60
H. Self-Appointed Medical Care
Decisions
Committees. 61
Question 3:
When and how should your
proxies be empowered
to make medical decisions?
63
A. Determining Your
Capabilities.
65
1. Background for Legal
Incompetence.
66
2. Power of Doctors to Declare
Incompetence. 67
3. Some Tests of Capability to
Make
Medical Decisions. 68
B. Voluntary Empowerment of Your
Proxies. 70
C. Continuing Cooperation between You and
Your Proxies. 73
D. Maintaining Your Settled Values if
You 'Change Your Mind'. 76
E. Changing Your Proxies.
77
F. When Your Proxies Might Go Beyond
Your Advance Directive. 78
PART II.
Quality-of-Life Issues
81
Question 4:
What level of personhood
do you wish to preserve thru medical care?
When—according to your own criteria—
would you become a former person?
81
A. Questions for Proxies
about
Consciousness
and Self-Consciousness. 82
B. Questions for Proxies about
Memory.
84
C. Questions for Proxies about Language
and Communication. 85
D. Questions for Proxies about
Autonomy.
88
Question 5:
Where do you draw the line
between a quality of life
worth preserving and the remnants of biological life
that should be mercifully shut down?
94
Question 6:
How do you want to be treated
if you get Alzheimer's disease
or some other condition that limits your mental
abilities? 97
PART III.
Pain Control, Nursing Home,
Financial Limits,
& Medical Information
103
Question 7:
If you are in serious pain,
what do you want done?
103
Question 8:
Do you want to be put into a nursing home?
If
so,
for how long, under what conditions, and for what
purposes? 106
Question 9: Where would you prefer to die? 112
Question 10: Will you put financial limits on your terminal care? 113
Question
11:
How much do you want to know
about your medical condition and prognosis?
115
PART IV.
Life-Ending Decisions
118
Question 12:
When should all curative
treatments be ended? 118
Question 13:
When should
Do-Not-Resuscitate orders
be written for you?
122
A. Avoid Blanket
Do-Not-Resuscitate
Orders. 124
B. Situations in which You Want to
Be
Resuscitated. 126
1. Drug
Overdose. 126
2. Electric
Shock. 126
3. Drowning.
126
4. Blood Loss.
127
5. Diabetic
Shock. 128
C. Situations in which You Do Not
Want
to Be Resuscitated. 129
1. You Are Expected to
Die. 129
2. You Cannot Tolerate Another
Resuscitation. 129
3. Resuscitation Would be
Medically
Futile. 129
4. You Have a Very Low Quality of
Life.
130
5. You Are Ready for Death to
Come.
131
6. You Are Already in an
Irreversible
Coma. 131
7. The Resuscitation is Dictated
by Institutional Policy
Rather than Personal
Need. 132
D. Some Special Situations for Resuscitation
Decisions. 133
1. "Slow Code"—Sham Resuscitation.
133
2. DNR as the Only Advance
Directive. 134
3. DNR in the Operating Room.
134
4. DNR in New York State —and other legislative
efforts. 135
5. DNR at Home.
137
6. Automatic DNR When Entering a Nursing Home or
Hospice. 137
Question 14:
How long should you be
maintained by life-supports? 138
Question 15:
Should food
and water
ever be
withdrawn or withheld
in order to
shorten
the process of your dying?
142
Question 16:
Do you endorse more active
means of ending your life?
Do you believe you have a right to die?
Voluntary death? Merciful Death?
144
Question 17:
Under what conditions would
you request death?
146
Question 18:
Do you wish to
join the
One-Month-Less Club? 150
Question 19:
Which definition of death
should apply to you? 152
A.
Brain-Death.
153
B. Coma or Permanent
Unconsciousness.
154
C. Persistent Vegetative
State.
155
PART V.
Disposition of Your Remains
158
Question 20:
Do you wish to donate your
organs
to other persons who need them?
158
A.
Ways of Increasing Organ-Donation.
160
1. Reasons for Not Donating
Organs.
160
2. Changes in Law to Increase
Organ-Donation. 163
3. Financial Incentives to
Increase
Organ-Donation. 166
B.
Coordinating Life-Ending Decisions with
Organ-Donation.
171
Question 21:
Will you donate your body
for use in medical science or education?
174
Question 22:
What other plans have you
made for your remains? 175
PART VI.
Philosophical-Religious Beliefs
& Readiness for Death
175
Question 23:
What philosophical, ethical,
or religious beliefs
do you hold that are relevant
to your medical care and other end-of-life decisions?
175
Question 24:
Are you ready to die
now? If yes, explain.
If no, what preparations (practical, interpersonal,
spiritual)
would make you more ready to die?
What projects do you wish to complete before you die?
181
PART VII. State
Forms, Supportive Statements, & Appendices
182
A. INTEGRATING YOUR
'LIVING WILL' INTO STANDARD
FORMATS 182
B. GETTING COOPERATION FROM YOUR DOCTORS
184
C. GETTING COOPERATION FROM YOUR
HOSPITAL 187
D. GETTING STATEMENTS OF COOPERATION FROM YOUR
PROXIES 188
E. DOCUMENTING THE PROCESS OF CREATING YOUR 'LIVING
WILL' 189
F. REVIEWING AND REVISING YOUR 'LIVING WILL'
PERIODICALLY 190
G. DISTRIBUTING COPIES OF YOUR ADVANCE
DIRECTIVE 191
James Park’s
Advance Directive for Medical Care
195
revised 3-23-2009
If you would like more
information about this book, go to:
Your Last Year:
Creating Your Own Advance Directive for Medical Care
by James Park.
Return to the MEDICAL ETHICS page.
If you would like to
see how the author answers
the 24 Questions himself,
click here for James
Park's Advance Directive.
If you would like to
read other books about
Advance Directives,
click here for Books
on Advance
Directives for Medical Care.
Return to the beginning
of this home page:
An
Existential Philosopher's Museum.