CollegeWriting.info: "How to Read College Texts"

Critical reading of literature is reading for academic or professional purposes--to analyze, review or argue about it. Critical reading of literature is not reading it just for pleasure, though some people are capable of doing both at the same time. Critical reading of literature usually means that in addition to understanding and enjoying a story, poem, play, or other literary form, you also are studying it so that you can write a paper or make a presentation about it. Often, at the college level, this means writing a paper for an English class.

When a person reads literature on his or her own, she usually just simply dives into it and enjoys it. However, critical reading of literature is different. You need to consider not just the story itself, but also

how the author constructed it
and
how additional meanings or interpretations may exist in it.

Once you have read a literary text critically, you are ready to start writing a paper responding to it. This section of CollegeWriting.info offers chapters on several ways to write to literature. If your instructor rather would have you write about a literary text using a more traditional method of composition and rhetoric--for example, some kind of thesis or related argument about it--you may prefer to read a chapter in one of two other sections in this online textbook: "Responding to Expository Readings" or "Arguing." However, if your instructor specifically wants you to write a type of literary paper such as a literary analysis, an interpretive literary thesis, or a critical review of literature, this is the correct section of CollegeWriting.info to study and use.

First, you should know that verbal, word-by-word method of reading is entirely appropriate and even required for reading poetry, no matter how long a poem or a set of poems might be. Poetry is a spoken art form: it requires you to hear the sounds and rhythms of the words, phrases, and lines as well as to picture the images and understand the ideas. For this reason, the best method of reading poetry is to literally read it aloud--to yourself or to a friend. In addition, you should do so at least three times: the first time is a preview, the second time is a look at the specific contents, and the third time is to understand the contents better and to start fixing specific descriptions, poetic patterns, images, and symbols in your mind. In truth, the majority of people who enjoy poetry or read it in their profession--and both literary scholars and casual poetry lovers are here included--make sure they read a poem at least three times and often more. If you are a student reading a poem for course discussion or writing, you may want to read it much more.

Brief short stories should be read in the same way. Many people accomplish this by reading stories to each other aloud. This is an excellent technique to pursue in study groups. It also can be very helpful to read a brief short story aloud to yourself. The very process of enunciating the words and phrases not only moves the sounds through a different part of your brain than if you are reading silently; moreover--and more importantly--you are much more likely to hear them the way the author wrote them and heard them him or herself. These two events combined are very powerful: the additional processing in your brain (beyond merely reading the words silently) makes it much more likely that you will remember what you have read, and hearing them as did the author means you are more likely to perceive the text as the author wanted it to be heard and read. Both of these events together place you in a strong and unique position to better discuss and write about the text in your course.

In addition, if you are to write or speak in class about specific elements of the text--especially those you quote--it is best to read these aloud to yourself several times. This insures not only that you understand them correctly but also that you are knowledgeable about their nuances--the more subtle or hidden meanings, feelings, tones, images, and/or symbols that may surround or be a part of them. Literary analysis and interpretation is the opposite of business or scientific writing in this respect: in the latter, you need to ignore minor feelings and imagination concerning your subject; however, in literary analysis and interpretation, you want to consider all such subtle feelings and imagination, for you may be able to propose ideas about passages and even about a whole text that few others have considered.

Should you read longer literary texts--like novels or plays--aloud? You may find that you are short on time, which is one good reason not to. However, reading longer works out loud usually is just as helpful and potentially meaningful as reading shorter works. In fact, often, the best method of reading literary works both short and long is to use several very different reading techniques: a quick skimming for organization, a longer silent reading (while taking initial notes), and an even longer reading aloud (while adding more notes). Using these techniques will help you remember the work much better, understand it much more deeply, and give you more material about which to write.

One of the great problems of reading literature is that most people read aloud in their heads--much as their parents read to them when they were growing up. Is this how you read? How are you reading this text right now--is their a small, silent "voice" in your head that reads each word, word by word? If so, you may wonder what other way there is to read. There is another way, and it can dramatically increase how quickly you can read. It is called "speed reading." It is a visual form of reading.

Speed reading, according to those who are strong supporters of it, claim that a person is more likely to remember details in a story by reading it faster. This is because the person has a better picture of the whole: of how the details on each page fit together on the page and in the chapter. Because of this, according to supporters of this system of reading, previewing a novel or story also is helpful: looking over key parts of a story briefly, before really reading the story, increases comprehension dramatically. The following information details how to preview, skim, and then speed read a longer text (such as a long story or a novel). These steps also are described in the "How to Read College Texts" chapter in the section called "Responding to Readings":

How should a person start reading? The least productive way is to dive in and start at the beginning. If you take a little bit of extra time to start by previewing and skimming--five to ten minutes for an essay, or twenty to sixty minutes for a book--you will save time in the long run and dramatically increase your comprehension at the very beginning of reading.

Previewing and skimming saved my grade average in a big way in school. Here is a story (from the "How to Read College Texts" chapter) about one course in which this happened dramatically. It happened when I was in graduate school. I was required to take a 600/6000-level graduate research-writing course. The instructor was the chair of the English Department, his doctoral dissertation had been a book-length manuscript on Charles Dickens, and he assigned us one Charles Dickens novel per week to read and to discuss every Wednesday evening for three hours. Dickens' famous A Christmas Carol, with Tiny Tim and Scrooge, is one of the author's shortest books. Most of them in paperback are six to twelve hundred pages long. The first two weeks, I spent about thirty hours per week reading the first two novels. I had time for nothing else, it seemed. By the fourth week, I discovered that Dickens had written his novels in such a way that they could easily be skimmed. I began applying a rich-text version of skimming, and I read Cliff's Notes for an hour or two each week. The result was that I spent about eight to ten hours each week--a third as much as before--and was one of only two students who continued the discussion of the week's novel with my instructor throughout the whole evening for all ten weeks of the course.

Use the following steps for previewing and skimming book-length literature. If you are reading a shorter work, such as a story or one-act play, skip to step "4."

Previewing

Cover or jacket: Read any descriptions or blurbs you can find about the book on the back or inside or it or on the book's cover jacket, and consider the possible meaning of the title of the book.
Introduction: If the book has a short introductory page or chapter, read it.
First and last pages: Read the first page or two of the first chapter, and the last page or two of the last chapter. This will tell you more precisely what the book is about.
Chapter beginnings and endings: Read the first and last paragraph of each chapter in the book. Glance at the graphics (pictures, diagrams, etc.). (If you are examining a story, one-act play, or long poem rather than a book, think about the title of the short text; then read the introductory and ending sections, which probably are one to several paragraphs each, and look at illustrations, if they exist.)

Skimming

Each page: Turn the pages as fast as you comfortably can, letting your fingers and hands determine the speed at which you turn the pages. Turn them at a steady rate, long enough to let your eyes light once, briefly, on each page. If there are titles, subtitles, or illustrations, you are welcome to look at them. Otherwise, simply let your eyes catch a word or phrase somewhere on each page. This may seem strange at first, but once you are done looking at the entire book this way--in ten or twenty minutes--you may find yourself surprised at how much you can guess about the contents of the story or its characters.
Paragraphs: For thorough previewing, read the first and/or last sentence of each paragraph.
Every word: The final step, if you have time, is to actually read all of the text, taking critical notes about it as you do so. You almost always will find, if you have previewed and skimmed your literary work first, that actually reading it word for word is easier, the notes you write are better, and your understanding of its deeper meanings is significantly better.

It is best, of course, to allow enough time to fully read a text without skimming. However, if you must skim, you may find it tempting--as you think and write notes about the contents--to stop skimming and read some paragraphs in more depth. This is an excellent technique--doing some skim-reading and some full reading--if you have the time. However, if your time is severely limited and you must choose, you may find it more practical to skim-read the entire document than to read only a part of it. Whichever method you choose, critical reading--thinking and writing notes about it--remains a necessary skill for full engagement of the text.

Speed reading means a reading of every phrase in a text, without skipping any parts of it, but in a much faster fashion than normal or average. Speed reading is a skill that requires practice. However, it is a very useful skill, for it can save many hours of time. The way speed reading works is that is transforms reading into a visual process only. The great majority of people read with a mixed visual and oral process. The visual part of it is the seeing of the letters on the page; at that point, most of the time, most people then "read" the words they see in their heads, as if reading aloud quietly to themselves. Most people's reading speed thus is limited to the speed with which they can "talk" fluently inside their heads. This is why most people can't read faster than twenty to forty pages per hour (or roughly one-half page per minute).

Speed reading changes the essential manner in which a person reads. In speed reading, you read faster than you can speak the words in your head. How is this accomplished? You learn to see the words--and only see them--rather than to turn them into a running monologue in your head. You do this by starting with one of the oldest reading habits in the world--a habit, in fact, that many early-elementary teachers try to prevent: you use your finger to read.

Does speed reading exclude other forms of reading? It doesn't. In fact, you can move back and forth between speed reading and normal reading, if this is what you want to do, or even between speed reading and skimming. However, you should try to plan enough time to read critically as you speed read. As a result, in good speed reading (as in good normal reading), there may be frequent starting and stopping so that you may respond to the text by writing notes. The most important element to remember in terms of the skill itself is that you can plan your method of reading (for example, by how many pages or paragraphs per hour you must read) according to how much time you have. However, the most important element to remember in terms of the content--of the assignment's meaning and purpose--is to plan your homework time so that even if you speed read, you have time to read critically.

The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the page author.The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by the University of Minnesota.

The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the page author.
The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by the University of Minnesota.