Study Questions for the Required Films
   

Cadillac Desert: Mercy of Nature

1.)1.) Use the story of water in California’s San Joaquin Valley to answer the following question: “Which was more important in the development of California: individual pioneers or the power of government?”


2.) What would California be like had the various California water projects not been undertaken?


3.) How does the story of the transformation of California’s San Joaquin Valley change our understanding of the environmental history of California? What is natural in California? What is perceived to be natural there? What tensions exist between these perceptions and the actual material reality?


4.) At the center of the story of water in California is the question of how humans use technology to transform their environment. What particular understanding of technology informed the various California water projects? What were/are the consequences of this understanding? What larger lessons about the proper relationship between humans, technology, and the environment do you draw from this story?


5.) Think about water in California in terms of democracy. Does the technological control and redistribution of water in California promote democracy? Why or why not? What does the history of water in California tell us about the forces shaping democracy in America in the twentieth century? What larger lessons about the proper relationship between technology and democracy do you draw from this story?


6.) The history of water in California and the history of Silicon Valley are both particular cases of the larger history of the making of the “American West.” What do these histories have in common? How do they illustrate the larger history of the “American West?” What role does technology play in this history, and how are technology and “the West” related?

 

The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the page author.
The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by the University of Minnesota.