This survey was
emailed out to all the senior design II advisors in early February
2006 by Mark Norland (President BMES 05-06), the responses that were
received are below
Q: What knowledge or knowledge area do you think biomedical engineering
students are currently lacking in and should know more about?
Q: What information should students know more about regarding
the BMEn industry (desirable skills, tools, etc.) before they get
into the industry?
Q: Additional comments or suggestions regarding what you
feel should be on the online resource center for future biomedical
engineering students (i.e. statistics, articles, links etc.)?
RESPONSES (5)
I suggest having an "events" link that takes you to bmes
events and
to seminars and other activities that may be of interest to biomed
students.
I suggest you recruit heavily for members in MechE and EE. Right
now
bmes is pretty tied to BME, but it need not be if we are to have
an
even stronger chapter in MN.
For events, let's have a *huge* student turn out at the 2006 DMD
conference, http://www.me.umn.edu/dmd/index.htm
Lots of good deals for students
http://www.me.umn.edu/dmd/dmd2006/students.htm
And the 2006 BMES Midwest mtg will happen at the same time
http://www.me.umn.edu/dmd/dmd2006/pdf/BMES%20Midwest%202006.pdf
At the 2005 BMES Midwest mtg (the first midwest ever), it was a
little embarrassing because while it was hosted at the U, there
were
more students from Marquette and Iowa than there were from the U.
Perhaps you could arrange it so that 100% of the BMES mbrs at the
U
participate this year? Contact Paul Iaizzo who would love to work
with you on this.
- WD
I apologize for not get back to you earlier. I applaud you efforts
to
gather information from industry for use by BMES to help prepare
the
students for life in industry.
In response to your first two questions, my philosophy is that
BMEn
students, more than most other disciplines, should become very skilled
in
the art of interdisciplinary learning. In addition to learning about
the
patients that the devices serve, the engineers should learn about
how to
determine what features to include in devices (voice of the customer
and
marketing) and how to effectively balance time to market with design
trade-offs, working well with others (emotional intelligence), how
to
determine trends (e.g., healthcare reimbursement), how to effectively
work
in teams, how to create a culture of innovation, individual performance,
how
to meet regulatory requirements (i.e., FDA, EU, etc.), how to pass
audits,
etc.
Links to organizations such as the FDA, Product Development and
Management
Association, World Future Society, Gallup Organization, specific
medical
organizations (e.g., American Urological Association), business
organizations, etc. would all be of use in my opinion.
As you can see, I believe it is important for people to have a
very
broad-based understanding that extends well beyond what is typically
considered to be "core curriculum".
Regards,
- KM
Assuming that most BME’s will be going on to industry and
not grad school, medical school, etc.
Materials actually used in practice. My experience with the BME
students is that they have learned about the science of biomaterials,
but not what materials are available, how they are processed and
the considerations for their use.
Processing techniques in general: injection molding, extrusion,
metal machining, use of adhesives, an understanding of tolerances,
screw thread design/selection, etc.
Reading and creating an engineering drawing according to industry
standards. The ME’s have an engineering graphics course
These are the things I spend the most time teaching when I have
hired a new BME grad
A1: Provide a link to the US Patent & Trademark Office (USPTO)
www.uspto.gov
The FDA www.fda.gov
Interactive injection molding training www.routsis.com
Understanding engineering drawings http://pergatory.mit.edu/2.007/Resources/drawings/
A1: The nuts and bolts of engineering as indicated above. They
would be miles ahead and more attractive to employers if they had
an understanding of these areas
- DA
A2: Core basics. Unfortunately, my company still likes people to
be either mechanical or electrical engineers for new hires. Thus
an ME should have a drafting class (to be able to read prints),
material science, fluid flow, etc. classes.
A2: That the industry still has certain biases against BMEn being
able to step into a traditional electrical or mechanical engineering
role. Not that they won’t hire a BMEN but only ones with experience.
Smaller companies are probably more open to BMEn’s than larger
companies ( speaking only for MN large companies). If an student
can get an internship with one of the companies they have a better
chance of changing that bias against BMEn’s.
A2: Listing of companies that are recruiting out of state. Students
need to be more flexible and be willing to move out of MN ( they
can always move back).
- JF
A3: : If students wish to pursue medical device product design,
then they lack in-depth working knowledge in one of the key engineering
disciplines, mechanical, electrical, or software. This would include
lab work. If the students are pursuing clinical support, then they
are not lacking much. In general what ought to be added is testing
methodologies and statistics.
A3: Again, a working knowledge in statistics, mean, variance, population
studies, statistically significant, in/out-of-control, common cause,
special cause, etc.. This is something that Deming taught that George
Washington University picked up.
A working knowledge in Verification and Validation testing. Bench
testing, lab testing, clinical testing, animal testing, etc. To
come up with a test plan and test protocols.
A3: test methods, websites: IEEE, ANSI, ASTM, AAMI, HFES,
- RS
|